Thursday, December 4, 2008

Twilight

As a youth pastor I have always tried to read what the kids in my ministry were reading. I got hooked on the Harry Potter series when a mother asked me if she should allow her son to read it. After I devoured the first book in the series I responded with a resounding "yes". So when the girls in my group began reading the Twilight series I took notice. Actually I thought to myself that perhaps this was one I could pass on. However, after more than a year or so of missing inside jokes related to the series I couldn't take it any more. Amanda (my youth ministry associate) brought me Twilight. I read it. It wasn't as bad as I thought, but there were definitely some goofy parts (as in the Potter series). The book details the blooming love of Isabella for a young man named Edward, who just happens to be a vampire forever stuck in a 17 year old body. Bella has moved to the pacific northwest to live with her father (parents divorced). Isabella feels alone, confused and is working out roles in her own home which is new to her since she hasn't lived with her father before. She is new to her school and she is stunningly awkward. The details Bella settling in at Forks (her town) and beginning her relationship with Edward.

So, why do girls like this? I am probably wrong here, but I will take a shot. My readers can set me straight or perhaps add more.

*Bella feel awkward and painfully normal but Edward finds her irresistible.
*Bella believes Edward is way out of her league...little did she know that he was out of her race.. ha ha.
*Bella and Edward spend entire days together asking each other questions
*Edward protects Bella
*Edward is strong (physically) and beautiful (Bella's words).
*Edward reveals his secrets only to Bella
*Edward takes Bella on adventures she cannot possibly imagine.
*They are chaste. A great line if the book was during a conversation they were having about love and lust. Edward suggested they were not always the same and perhaps that Bella had been involved physically before without really loving someone. Bella sets they record straight by telling him for her the two were not exclusive from one another.
*Edward can read others thoughts, but not Bellas, he has to ask her what she is thinking.
*Edward has the wisdom of a hundred year old man in the body of a 17 year old.
*Edward desires to drink Bellas blood but resists because of his love for her.
*They set boundaries for their relationship. Bella would fully give herself to Edward (and become a vampire) but he will not allow her to.
*They laugh a lot together
*Edward makes her go to the prom.

Implications?

I think that Twilight speaks to the often unspoken desires of everyone...We want to feel special. We want to feel secure. We long for relational intimacy. We want boundaries. We need unconditional love to thrive and be truly human.

Parents, I approve this message and the message of Twilight. I haven't read the entire series, but I have heard that the themes listed continue throughout the series.

Now, back to my Robert Ludlum and Jason Bourne...

5 comments:

Sherill said...

I think you are on the mark! Having read all 4 (It helps at times to at least try and be a cool mom ;-D ) My only real concern was that Bella continually puts herself in dangerous situations whether it is behaving foolishly sensual or crashing motorcycles,or jumping off cliffs. I also was uncomfortable with her deep depression in the second book because (plot spoiler alert) Edward leaves her. She makes teenage angst seem romantic and deep depression seem like a sign of true love.

On the other hand, I did enjoy the books. But now I too am on to other types of books.

jason said...

Andy Milonakis gets 4 comments - deep thoughts on Twilight gets 1 comment...and that is the story of the internet in a nutshell.

Dee Ann said...

I'm about half way through the first book. I must say, Harry Potter was a more compelling read. But Sara loves the books and is reading them. I can't say the same for the Harry Potter books - although she enjoyed the movies. I guess that matters?

Sherill said...

Here is a real interesting article that compares Twilight with 4 Christmases Movie Ministry

googler said...

balenciaga handbag
balenciaga handbags
balenciaga
balenciaga bags